Anyone have a shaped ER but a "normal" shaped wedding band?

My ER doesnt have a twist but the setting is bigger so have been told my WR could do with being shaped.

However, I went to the jewellers yesterday and the guy in their said it doesn't necessarily need to be shaped and got me to try on a normal band.

It looked perfectly fine, but for me I know it would annoy me that it doesnt sit quite right (just my OCD coming out lol) so will def be having it shaped.

Also, he did make a good point that lots of people will only wear their WR so if it was really shaped would look odd.

HTH x

Very similar to mine, and i love the way my two rings look together but then i guess i'm biased. Not keen on shaped wedding bands tbh x

Me!

I dont have a pic but it is kind of like this but a bit bigger (diamond slightly bigger and thicker band)

and I have a normal shaped wedding ring, it has diamonds in it too and I wear them together and think they look great, I think its a taste thing most of my friends with shaped ERs got shaped WRs but Im another one who really dislikes shaped WRs and although my rings dont sit together I love them!

I have no idea how to get pictures on to here but my e-ring is very similar to this one (possibly this actual one)

https://www.hkjewellery.co.uk/details/web/type/rings/id/3393

I did have a plain wedding band made to fit around the heart shape, however I now have an eternity ring which is the same as your wedding band and is straight. I thought I was going to wear the eternity ring on the other hand as it would look silly having the straight band next to a curved one. However it looks fine, I can't imagine them all not being together now. Yours will look lovely together and very sparkly !

My ER has a slight twist but I didn't want a shaped WR so I've gone for a really thin band it has diamonds going half way round, I think it looks lovely, I think if you've tried them on together and you like the way it looks that's all that matters.

I have and E ring a lot like Naboos pic (but the diamond sits a little higher).

I've chosen this

as a good compromise as I didn't like most shaped rings on their own, but also had an issue with the gappage going on.

Also considered

but decided that the bands forming the crossover weren't the right width for my ER and the shaping wasn't perfect.

Whatever feels right and looks right to you! Its you whos wearing them. No right or wrong answer here, its an individuals choice! My opinion is that both your rings are gorgeous! x

Randomsabreur - where is this ring from? Its lovely...

I have twisted ER too, and I want a shaped WR but cant find anything I like

I considered something similar but when I tried it on it just didn't feel like "my" ring!

Thanks for the replies ladies, and the flashes are very helpful! I'm glad other people have gaps, makes me feel better about my own ?

Jules'n'Mark, thanks for the compliment!

H Samuel of all places - both were from there! Was very surprised and impressed!