Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

J
Beginner August 2013

Anyone with cats or know about cats

jessica_jayne, 12 March, 2012 at 14:03 Posted on Off Topic Posts 0 5

Hi all,

I took my 10 month old female kitten to the vets this morning for her to be neutered. He checked her heart beat, checked his records asked whether she had her jabs etc.. told him she had, he then said she had a heart murmur, and we should of been told about this, then told him that we had everything done at the same vets. He then backtracked on the fact they never told us.

He said we can still have her neutered but she will be in a higher risk, or pay for a heart scan which is £185 plus medication.

He then went old to tell us this could never affect her or they could find further problems.

She isn't insured, it's been one of those things on a list you've got to get sorted. He said if she needed surgery where looking in the thousands.

As most people on here are in similar situations, we are saving every spare penny to the wedding, and haven't budgeted for this, she is my priority but he said if she wasn't fixed getting pregnant could cause strain on her heart as could the op to get her fixed. £185 is a lot to spend on a scan for them to say she is fine so I came out saying I would ring them back.

I explained as well that my partner is a self employed builder, I'm a full time student so income is low. Spoke to my mum and she told me to ring around cat charities. Rung Cat Protection, who are now sending us a voucher towards getting her fixed and I mentioned what the vet said about the heart murmur.. he said this was weird because they are doing research with University of Bristol, who are looking into hear murmurs.

He said their findings show that nearly all cats have a heart murmur and it could be that hers was today, and it could of gone back to normal next week, which has left me wondering if a. she needs a scan and b. whether the vet was telling me everything or just wanting extra money.

If anyone has any advice or has a cat with this problem, your help would really be appreciated xx

5 replies

Latest activity by McSquirtle, 12 March, 2012 at 15:52
  • JennyH10
    Beginner May 2013
    JennyH10 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    All of the above make the cynic in me think that your answer is B I'm afraid.

    Don't hand over any money until you have seen another vet for a second opinion (don't tell the new vet about this possible murmur) go to a recommended one if you can find one. Have you been in touch with the PDSA? If you're on a low income you might be able to get the cat treated by them for a reduced fee/donation.

    • Reply
  • HatTrick
    Beginner September 2010
    HatTrick ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I don't think the vets would be that hard up for £185 that they 'exaggerate' and recommend scanning if there's no need for it? IME they make enough money as it is!

    When we took my cat to be neutered we were told he had a heart murmur but we went ahead without the tests that they recommended (he was fine). What grade did they say it was? FWIW he still has the heart murmur.

    • Reply
  • BumbleBrat
    BumbleBrat ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'd be going to a different vet practice for another opinion.

    I have 2 cats, one was found to have a heart murmur last March, it was only found when he had a bad respiratory infection. I was told he could grow out of it, but will continue to have annual check-ups to make sure it isn't worsening. Your vet should have been able to tell you the grade of the heart murmur to gauge how bad it is, did he/she not?

    • Reply
  • kittykat9/9
    Beginner October 2011
    kittykat9/9 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    My vet will tell us what to do depending on whether we have insurance or not - there are some tests that he says "let's just see what happens" when we say we don't have insurance but if our moggy was insured he would have done it. I would get a second opinion and completey agree with the recommendation for the PDSA - they're there for people on low incomes so if you qualify they will be great.

    Good luck x

    • Reply
  • J
    Beginner August 2013
    jessica_jayne ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Thank you every one.

    I think it was just how he questioned me why the vet had never told us about the murmur when she first was checked out, as because she is only 10 months he thinks she was born with it.

    When I said it was by your company just at another branch, he then made out like 'o well it may just be sudden then.'

    He never said what rate the murmur was, i kept asking his opinion on how bad it was and he said he couldn't tell me anything unless i had the scan for her.

    £185 + might not be alot to them, but when its unexpected it's alot to me.

    I came home, rung pdsa, rspca but none of them are in our catchment area or we don't qualify. Rspca put me onto Cat Protection who said we qualified for a voucher towards neutering. I asked about murmurs, thats when he said about the research just carried out by Uni of Bristol vets, and he said that nearly all cats have these murmurs that come and go.. thats why i was spectacle.

    I think I am deffo going to take her to another vets, not tell them and see if they detect it then tell them about it after whether or not they do detect it.

    This might be a silly questions, but will a new vet find out about a cats records from a previous vets or what you tell them?

    Thank you for all your advice

    • Reply
  • McSquirtle
    Beginner June 2011
    McSquirtle ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    A lot of kittens are born with murmurs that often rectify themselves. The vet will be able to tell you what grade the heart murmur is and this will effect how risky the spay will be. I have done many spays of patients with murmurs and it's more of a worry about the drugs used, however the risks can be minimised now that they know about the heart problem. I would definitely get a second opinion but with most heart murmurs being grade 1 or 2, if this is the case it wouldn't affect her too much and getting her neutered is definitely more important!

    Hth somewhat. I'm on my phone do can't read back, apologies for typos, grammar and general nonsense ?

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

General groups

Hitched article topics