Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Bohemian Raspberry
Beginner July 2009

Argh! Car Insurance

Bohemian Raspberry, 27 January, 2009 at 16:26 Posted on Off Topic Posts 0 13

I'm 21 and I passed my driving test last March. When we bought my car, the cheapest insurance policy we could find was nearly 3k so we registered the car in OH's name, he insured it and added me as a named driver. This brought the policy down to about 1k (I can't remember exactly off the top of my head). Our insurance is now up for renewal as the policy was a 10 month bonus accelerator but even though we haven't claimed, the premium has gone up to near enough £1500 for another 10 month policy.

I've been searching for quotes and the difference between different insurers and policy types is mind boggling. For example, I got a quote from Swift Cover, insuring the car in my name only and the premiums were £97 per month. I then got another quote with me still as the main driver, but with OH as a named driver. This brought it down to £85 per month. I then got another quote with OH as the main driver and me as a named driver. This came out as £147 per month! Surely it should be cheaper with him as the main driver as he's had his licence for 5 years and he's never had any accidents etc?

Now I'm not going to argue if they'll insure it in my name for £85 a month (that's a bargain to me!) as this means I get the no claims discount but OH can still drive it if needs be(OH has a company car which is our main car) but why is there so many price variations? I'm so confuzzled, it's not like I'm driving a flipping tank either, it's only a little 206.

13 replies

Latest activity by Boxof BaldKittens, 27 January, 2009 at 18:29
  • Dooby
    Beginner
    Dooby ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Car insurance is a bit of a mysterious thing i reckon. If I were you i'd take a look at the £85 per month quote with you as the main driver, presuming that it covers all you want it to it sounds like a good option. As you've not been driving long you want to start building up your own no claims bonus and seeing as your OH has a car of his own already insured in his name he won't be missing out.

    Presuming that you're female it may be that you've come across one of the special "women drivers" policies that insurance companies do, i think it's something to do with some statistic somewhere that reckons women are less likely to be involved in an accident than men? I've no idea whether that's true or not but hey if the insurance companies want to give you a good deal as a result who are we to argue eh! ?

    • Reply
  • K
    Beginner May 2007
    Kegsey ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    The price differences sound right to me. It'll be going up with your OH as main driver as men are statistically more likely to claim on their insurance (or be claimed upon). If you are the main driver of the 206, then you should be the policy holder. Keep shopping around (for this year and subsequent ones) to find the best quote you can. As you get older and get more no claims bonus's (?), then your insurance should go down.

    • Reply
  • Flaming Nora
    Beginner May 2003
    Flaming Nora ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    3K to insure a 206? Blimey ?

    Insurance can be a nightmare and rarely makes sense to me. My students often tell me its cheaper for hem to be insured fully comp than just 3rd pary and quite often if they get added to parents/partners policy it brings the premium down, despite them being learners. Its all very odd.

    Have you tried the price comparison sites? £85 a month with yout OH having 5 years no claims and you having 1 year, seems way too much to me.

    • Reply
  • Sunset21
    Beginner
    Sunset21 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Have a look at doing the insurance through Quidco aswell, there's usually cashback incentives. If you call the insurer they'll sometimes give a bit more discount aswell. I was with Privilege but rang them to say I was cancelling and I managed to get another discount out of them, an internet discount or something.

    • Reply
  • Flaming Nora
    Beginner May 2003
    Flaming Nora ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Just to add, some companies now do cheaper premiums if you don't drive the car in certain hours (such as midnight to 6am) It can make a dramatic difference as most new driver accidents happen during them times. Might be worth considering.

    • Reply
  • Zooneycat
    Zooneycat ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Insurance is a very strange thing. It was about £1k cheaper to add me to MrZ's policy on his car, yet when i put him on mine, it went up slightly! Meh!

    It should be cheaper for you to be the main driver, and have him as a named driver. also look at putting your Mum, or someone female (pref related), with excellent no claims on the insurance.

    • Reply
  • Bohemian Raspberry
    Beginner July 2009
    Bohemian Raspberry ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    FN, I've quotes going up to 5k, the car isn't even worth that! The quotes I've been getting are from comparison sites and then I've been ringing up the cheapest to see if I can get it down a bit more.

    That's why we insured the car in OH's name originally, it was far, far cheaper than insuring it my name. My dad who's been driving for more than 50 years got a quote for my car with me as a name driver and they came out with £1900! I got a third party quote from Swift Cover (who I'm talking about in my OP) and it was only £6 a month cheaper than being insured fully comp.

    Neither of us techinically have any no claims, when he had his own car he was a named driver on his dad's policy so he didn't earn any and for the past 3 years he's had his company car. I haven't got any NC as our last policy only had me as a named driver, so OH got the NCD but it's non transferrable unless we stay with our current insurers.

    I have to nip out now but I'll check this thread again later.

    • Reply
  • Lady Falafel
    Beginner April 2006
    Lady Falafel ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I thought the registered owner had to be the main driver, or have I got that wrong?

    • Reply
  • Bubbub
    Bubbub ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    You are right LF. . What the OP is doing is known in the industry as "fronting" and is classed as fraud. The policy can be voided if you are caught out doing this

    • Reply
  • Bohemian Raspberry
    Beginner July 2009
    Bohemian Raspberry ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Thanks for all the replies, it's just so confusing where they get their figures from.

    LF, we'd change the ownership of the car to me if I end up being the main driver on the insurance.

    • Reply
  • Boxof BaldKittens
    Boxof BaldKittens ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I've learnt something new today then. I know lots of people who do this. For my small and confuddled mind, how can you be caught?

    • Reply
  • Lady Falafel
    Beginner April 2006
    Lady Falafel ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    If you write off the car for example, you'll have to return all the documents to them.

    • Reply
  • Bubbub
    Bubbub ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Some people are also daft enough to admit it in the course of discussing a claim or you could be caught out by an engineer discussing a vehicle that you clearly dont have any working knowledge of or use.

    • Reply
  • Boxof BaldKittens
    Boxof BaldKittens ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    ? you both. Makes sense now.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now