Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Clairy
Beginner October 2003

Blimey - what do you make of this?

Clairy, 5 February, 2009 at 12:39 Posted on Off Topic Posts 0 14

I have a Great Aunt, my Gran's sister, who is 80. My Gran died 10 years ago. I have always kept in touch with Aunty Ruth because there have been parallels between her life and mine and, obviously, because I am fond of her. This has always taken the form of a letter and we have been in touch on and off for the past 15 years. Some of the things we have shared have been quite initimate - I wrote to her a lot during my marriage break up and she was lovely and kind.

She's the youngest of 5 and is widely known in the family as being a bit of an oddball. However, she has had some horrible things happen to her - she had TB when she was a child, she had an abusive husband and left him taking nothing, at a time when there was a real stigma surrounding being a single Mum. Her son was mentally ill and she put up with years of physical and emotional abuse from him before he died suddenly of heart failure in his 30s. She's bitter and prone to lengthy bouts of self pity (and, I am sure, depression.) I just tend to take her as I find her. I write to her once or twice a year and sometimes she responds, sometimes she doesn't. She didn't want to come to our wedding, and will do almost anything to avoid any sort of social activity. From an outsider's perspective she seems to refuse all offers of company, and then feels that she's all alone and no-one cares.

Anyway, I wrote to her at Christmas with a little family update. She hasn't responded for quite a few years now - probably about 5. Today, I received this letter (verbatim) with a cheque for £200:

"Hello there

Thank you for your letter. It did my heart good to read how you (and your H) put your boys first being interested in their football and the garden.

I was six years old spend six months in hospital and six at home, not once did my mother try to teach me to read or spell.

I left school the bottom of the class. The money is for the two boys.

Please do not send me a thank you present.

Just carry on the good work.

Love Aunty Ruth xxxx"

I don't know how to feel and I certainly don't know how to respond. I feel embarrassed. Sometimes it feels as though she thinks I stay in touch so she will give me money - this is absolutely not the case.

How would you feel and what would you do next? Maybe I am too close to the situation and feel as though she is being a little bit manipulative. However, this could just be family history. I think the main reason it feels weird is because she's not spoken to me once, not even chit chat, in over 5 years, and then sends this letter and a cheque.

14 replies

Latest activity by Mambo, 5 February, 2009 at 13:02
  • Tulip O`Hare
    Beginner
    Tulip O`Hare ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It sounds to me as though she wants to do something for your boys, especially since she knows how it feels to have very little when you're young. Almost as if she wants to make it up to them for what happened to her?

    I would just send her a lovely thank you card, and not try to read too much into it. She wouldn't have sent the money if she didn't want to.

    • Reply
  • HeidiHole
    Beginner October 2003
    HeidiHole ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It sounds like she thinks you're doing a good job, and has sent you some money to treat the boys. The money isn't for you, as it were, so I don't think you've anything to feel bad about.

    Clearly there are issues here that we know nothing about, but am failing to see the problem if I'm honest. I would send her a card/letter to say thank you, and maybe a photo of the boys in their football kits or something.

    • Reply
  • Hungry Caterpillar
    Beginner
    Hungry Caterpillar ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I would say it's very generous of her. It sounds like she hasn't got a lot of close family and that she appreciates your contact with her. Although she has requested to not send a thank you present, I would send a nice card, with a note inside saying that her gift was much appreciated, that you will spend it on something for the boys (maybe say what?) and maybe send her a photo of the boys?

    • Reply
  • Flump
    Expert January 2012
    Flump ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Just taking this on face value, I think it's really sweet and she appreciates the updates you send her even if she struggles (poss cos of depression) to do the same back. She's had the energy to do it this time, and wanted to show her appreciation with the cheque for your boys.

    Spend the money on whatever for the boys, take a photo, and send it with a note as a thank you. Why would she assume you only stay in touch for the money? has she sent you money randomly before? Are you sure you're not reading too much into it?

    She sounds lovely, I'm sorry she's had so much sorrow in her life xx

    • Reply
  • Tilly Floss
    Tilly Floss ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I would send photos of the family, especially the boys, with a lovely thank you card.

    • Reply
  • Clairy
    Beginner October 2003
    Clairy ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Yeah, maybe so. I'm actually glad that you both think that.

    I know she has had a tough life, I just don't know what to say to her about it. Her sentences are always short and blunt, but that's probably because of the reasons that she mentioned in her letter (which I didn't know about before today)

    My paranoia is that she thinks I only stay in touch with her because I want her money. She's made those sorts of comments to other family members who have tried to befriend her in the past (not about me, I hasten to add.) However, it's not true - I like her, she's been a real help to me in the past, and I miss my Gran and she feels like a link to her. I write to her because I am fond of her - and she almost finds that harder to deal with than sending money.

    Does that make sense? I think this is just about awkward Britishness ?

    • Reply
  • MrsDoris
    Beginner
    MrsDoris ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I think I'd feel a bit embarrassed as well at first but I think it's a lovely gesture on her behalf and you should accept it as such. I would just keep writing to her and keeping her informed of your boys' development as it seems to give her pleasure. Do something with the money for the boys and maybe send her some photos of them enjoying whatever it is (even if you only spend a little bit and put the rest in the bank).

    I agree about sending her a note, thanking her too.

    • Reply
  • ebee
    Beginner January 2008
    ebee ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    If you have written personal letters before, then i think I would respond in writing, saying pretty much what you have here ... along the lines of - thankyou for the money, you will buy the boys something lovely with it, but you would be very embarrassed and upset if she thought the reason you kept in contact was to keep in her favour. In fact, you're very fond if her, and feel that you have a lot in common and have valued the relationship you've formed over the years. However, the gift is appreciated and is a very kind gesture.

    ? I wouldn't over analyse... she's perhaps getting to the stage in life where she has money but nowhere to spend it so wants to see it making someone else happy..

    • Reply
  • Zebra
    Beginner
    Zebra ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Bless, I'd send a card saying thank you, you were very touched and that you'll do X with it forthe boys. I'd send the a pic too.

    I'd take the letter at face value and I'd not worry about her thinking you're only after money or whatever - she's clearly fond of you and it sounds like she's happy with the way your relationship is with her; thoughtful but at adistance.

    If you take it at face value then you're not open to manipulation - if things change in the future then rethink if necessary.

    • Reply
  • Mookey
    Mookey ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    Exactly WSS

    It doesn't sound at all as if you have been writing to her because of the money, and I doubt she sees it that way at all. You've still been writing to her even though she hasn't responded, and I think people generally know who a good person is.

    • Reply
  • Clairy
    Beginner October 2003
    Clairy ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'm reading too much into this, aren't I? ?

    I've just read my post back with your comments in mind, and reading the letter not in her handwriting I can see what you all mean.

    The boys and I are really into making things at the moment - I'll get them to make her a picture or something, and write a thank you letter too.

    Thank you all for the perspective. I think I just knew what my mother would say ?

    • Reply
  • SophieM
    SophieM ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I would get the boys to write to her thanking her and telling her what you/they will be doing with the money.

    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner February 2008
    Mambo ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Given that she has told other people she thnks they are after her money, it seems she wouldn't give it to you if she though that was what you were after.

    I hope your boys have fun with it and I agree about sending a card and photo.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now