Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

M
Beginner

Giving away long rant...

maris1111, 16 March, 2010 at 13:52 Posted on Planning 0 5

Having a bit of an issue in terms of who is giving me away and how not to upset everyone. My Dad passed away 7 years ago, and my Mum had remarried a couple of years before that. I don’t hate my Stepdad in any way but his behaviour can be a lot to tolerate, it was much better after I left for university and he wasn’t there all the time. After so long living by himself he got very set in his own ways, se he hates any noisiness and sulks if anything happens outside his set routine. I know that he does care a great deal and he’d like to see himself as my Dad substitute and really love to give me away but I just don’t feel that he would be the right person, ideally I’d rather have someone more connected to my Dad.

I also have two brothers, one older and one younger, and my Dad’s brother I also know would love to do it. My Dad’s side of the family do not get on with my Mum and Stepdad, but I thought the easiest plan of action would be to ask my Mum as we’ve always been quite close and she did a lot for us when my Dad was ill when we were younger. She agreed, but didn’t want to do a speech so I just said my Stepdad could do that part as I didn’t really mind. I even told my Grandma (Dad’s Mum) that I was just doing that as a compromise as she was suggesting my older brother, so I thought all was now sorted.

But now over Mother’s Day dinner with my parents and H2B’s parents my Mum announced that she doesn’t want to do it any more, she wants to be standing at the front looking glamorous and watching me come down the aisle. So because she said yes at first and I didn’t specifically tell her otherwise, it appears that they have both made the assumption that if she doesn’t want to do it I’ll want my Stepdad and I really don’t. Now he’s going to be really upset as I don’t mind him doing a speech but I don’t want him walking me down. Because she announced it over dinner so publicly I couldn’t then discuss it, and they didn’t stick around long after that as they had to get back. It’s a pain as I spent all day on Saturday alone with my Mum and she didn’t mention any of it. Now I have no idea when I can get her on her own, she never has her phone on and they’re both always at home.

If I ask one or both brothers to do the honours I don’t know whether they will want to do speeches or not, so I could potentially be taking everything away from my Stepdad which was never my intention. My Mum doing it was meant to be the plan so nobody would be offended and now it has backfired on me. I don’t want to force my Mum if she doesn’t want to but if she has to tell him he can’t he’s going to be a huge nightmare for her to live with. Still, I’m not going to be pushed into doing something I’m not happy with on my wedding day, its just how to go about it.

5 replies

Latest activity by debmci, 16 March, 2010 at 19:35
  • Maxibon
    Beginner March 2009
    Maxibon ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I think ur mum knows shes in the wrong or she would have said something during the day...and not some big announcement?

    You need to decide who you do want, make sure they want to do it, and then tell your mum and s-dad together. theres no point saying he's not doing it, and getting stuck again and having to ask him. If they are hurt then explain that your mum had no right assuming he could do it in her place. you could say you asked him to do a speech as you love him, but want to remember your dad on YOUR special day.

    xxx

    • Reply
  • fancyfree
    Beginner April 2010
    fancyfree ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    In this case, it seems walking down alone would be most diplomatic. Would you consider that?

    • Reply
  • Bob - An Image For You
    Bob - An Image For You ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    How about either of the following:

    Older brother gives you away, Step dad does the speeches. Make sure step dad agrees to it as you don't want any assumptions and have him ruin it on the day. If he does not agree, then ask your dad's brother to do speeches.

    If brother will not do it, then ask dad's brother to do it. Again, if step dad will not do speeches, ask older brother. If he will not, then ask dad's brother to do both (give you away and also the speeches).

    I hope you get the person(s) you really would like to.

    • Reply
  • Houdini
    Beginner August 2010
    Houdini ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'd get both of your brothers to walk you down the aisle and leave your s-dad to do the speech. If your brothers want to do a speech as well then I'd have their one as an additional speech, not isntead of your s-dad.

    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner
    maris1111 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I wouldn't mind doing it solo its just that if I do that and then let him make the speech it would still be like I'm giving him the honour and noone else that I do feel closer to any responsibility or anything. Unless I then either had no speech, or let everyone do a speech!

    I'm thinking of trying to talk to just my Mum first and explaining where I'm coming from then I can ask my brothers if they would want to and if they'd be wanting to give a speech or happy to just walk me up.

    • Reply
  • debmci
    debmci ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    My friend's dad died when we were very young but her mum has never re-married. she had 2 older brithers and the oldest one gave her away and the other one was a groomsman, as he was good friends with the groom. it was lovely her brother giving her away.

    you could also have a wee chat with your mum and just let her know that it was something really important to you that she did it for you. she might do it if she realised hown important it was to you.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now