Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Studying&Planning
Beginner April 2014

No Children - am standing by my guns - but is it worth it?

Studying&Planning, 11 February, 2014 at 09:19 Posted on Planning 0 17

So, the big day was always going to be child free, we don't have any, and our friends that do are more than happy to leave them at home, ours will hopefully be the last wedding of the friendship group (barring any more divorces) so people want to kick back and really enjoy themselves.

We have two nieces though (8 & 10). So, we came up with a plan, as we are legally getting married in a registry office the week before, they could come to that, look after the rings, we've bought them party frocks, not bridesmaid dresses, we can then take them out for a lunch somewhere where they will actually eat the food, rather than complain and poke it saying "what's this" and don't have to sit through a 3 hour affair, with speeches. The venue is TINY, and there is no where for them to play. AND they can't even get through a simple family meal at the local pub without being glued to an electronic device and refuse to put it down when the meal arrives..

We went to see their parents (OH's brother & sister-in-law) to say we were getting married and what the deal was, SIL's immediate reaction was "well, that's fine, it's your day have it how you want". Hmm.. Now the fun an s games.

Since then, she has said at every meeting, things like, but the girls really want to meet your mum n dad, then, it seems like a shame to just wear their dress one day (like that doesn't happen at a regular wedding), then this weekend a family lunch, "can't they just come to the ceremony and then disappear?"

my immediate response was a firm "no, they are coming to a ceremony" to which she replied "but it's not a fairy tale one". I think her issues has come from the fact, when the girls and I were looking at dresses together, she kept telling them it needed to be pale to match my dress (they've chose bright red and navy blue - one colour each), when I told her I won't be rocking the big white dress at the registry office she was very surprised. The registry office, is just for us, 2 witnesses and the 2 nieces. I think then she realised it was mainly a ticking the box event.

My issue is, if I now say yes to the ceremony, then the next it'll be can they stay for the photo's, then it'll be there's plenty of room, can't they just stay for the meal and leave when the party starts - then where do you draw the line. I know for a fact the husband of one of my friends isn't coming because we have said no kids.

This is a bit of a pointless post - but am I just being an idiot, or am I being fair? We laid out our stall very early on, and they agreed. We're doing a load of cool things with the girls instead that we know they will actually enjoy, and the venue is on the bank of the river Thames, if they run a round outside there's going to have to be someone on guard duty all day.

17 replies

Latest activity by RLB, 11 February, 2014 at 13:10
  • MrsDJG
    Beginner May 2015
    MrsDJG ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Stick to your guns! Like your SIL said initially, it's your day! xx

    • Reply
  • bliss_balloons
    bliss_balloons ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I don't really see a problem with them being there the whole day to be honest, you'll hardly notice them and they'll have there parents there to look after them and keep them entertained so you don't have to worry about that. Why don't you want them in the photos? If it's because you can't invite friends children then you could just put in the invites, due to numbers we are only about to invite close family children.

    • Reply
  • AuntieBJ
    Beginner September 2014
    AuntieBJ ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    ^^^ this. Family children are different aren't they?

    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner August 2014
    MOMB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'm usually the one espousing the virtues of family but in this case I think you've been more than fair. You have planned a formal adult affair and want people to be able to let their hair down in an adult environment. Stick to your guns!

    • Reply
  • Mrspetal
    Beginner February 2014
    Mrspetal ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It's hard but look at the bigger picture, you won't even know they are there.

    The place will be filled with family and friends.

    We didn't want kids to come to start with but we have let a few come. If they get unruly or play up then several members of my family (quite well spoken!) have orders to tell the parents to sort them out or take them home!

    • Reply
  • H
    Beginner August 2014
    H3LEN ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    This way the girls get one on one time with you both. I doubt you will get the time on your party day. Tell the SIL this way you include them. I don't see a problem with it, and we've got children coming to our wedding. It's your day do what you want.

    • Reply
  • Sam&Louise
    Beginner September 2015
    Sam&Louise ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I anticipate that we'll be in a similar situation when our wedding gets a little closer, so I completely empathise!

    Personally, I think if you've made a decision already and have firm, clear reasoning for making that decision then you should stick to your guns. I (we) fully intend to so that we're able to enjoy our day in the way we would like and the way we have planned. I think it's lovely that you've made an effort to include them in the legal bit-it sounds like an all round more enjoyable experience for an 8 & 10 year old IMO.

    Only you can really say whether it's worth sticking with your decision or not. If you feel that having the girls there will change your day in a way that you're not comfortable with, then by all means go with it and remain firm. If however it's going to cause upset, arguments or a family rift then consider the implications of that too and whether you feel, on balance, it's worth it for the day you want.

    Good luck, hope they make it easy for you and back down!

    • Reply
  • Foo
    Beginner June 2014
    Foo ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Honestly don't get why you would not invite your own neices to your wedding. They want to be at the actual wedding to see you in your dress and have fun on the dancefloor and be part of the family. Offering them the second best legal bit is no compensation and making assumptions about what is better for them is not your job.

    I am actually forcing my sister to bring my nephew even though she doesn't really want to. ? He is as much a part of my family as she is and I would hate for him to not be there.

    • Reply
  • Studying&Planning
    Beginner April 2014
    Studying&Planning ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Thank you all, I knew this would split people down the middle. But it's nice to know I'm not going completely crazy - thank you,

    We're going for a super grown up affair, and figured we could have fun with the girls separately. It's not about keeping them out of the photo's and TBH SIL offloads the kids at her mothers all the time to go out with her friends, we thought she'd be on the same page here.

    If brother or MIL were mentioning I'd be getting really worried about possible rifts, but it's just something SIL says to me when no one else is listening. Just 8 weeks to go then the petty arguments about all sorts of wedding things will be all over, and we can get back to living in our bubble of love.

    • Reply
  • SillyWrong
    Beginner October 2014
    SillyWrong ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It's quite sad really that people aren't being supportive both IRL (your SIL) and here.

    It's your wedding, you've made your decisions, planned it how you want it, made sure that the girls are included. Stick to your guns. I don't think it's OK for anyone, a member of your family or a stranger on the internet to question why you've made your decisions the way you have and tell you that you should just have them along.

    Do what you feel is right for you and OH on your day.

    • Reply
  • SillyWrong
    Beginner October 2014
    SillyWrong ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    This. Don't take your eye off the bigger picture Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • bliss_balloons
    bliss_balloons ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I thought the op was asking for advice / opinions though?

    • Reply
  • G
    gpc1 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    As a father going to a wedding with no children allowed, a wedding photographer who has seen both options, and a husband who had no children allowed to our wedding (adult affair, black tie etc) i think i can see it from all sides.

    There is no right or wring. You have planned your day, you have a dream, you have your wish for a day that you want to be perfect. Nowt wrong with that.

    You have family who want to bring their children to share your beatiful day...understandable

    You have 2 children who are excited at the thought if a fairytale wedding.....and why wouldnt they be, Kids love weddings.

    No right / wrong.....but perhaps a compromise could be reached. ie they come for the ceremony but leave before the evening to allow the grown ups to party. Thatway they see the fairytal, can be in some of the shots, share the moment but are off before the adult time.

    Im sure if you explain it i such a way as this is the only deal / compromise they will understand. But, if you are going to be aware / concious that they are there and it will make you less relaxed and risks you being tense on your big day then stand firm and say no.

    The best thing here is communicaiton and open honest discussion with family. They need to understand your wishes and accept that its your day and whilst you are open to suggestions and copmpromise your decision is made for a reason.

    Not sure that helps...

    all the best

    • Reply
  • PinkButterfly
    Beginner June 2014
    PinkButterfly ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I dunno.... I'm having a child free wedding! (Yep I'm the 'mean' one who won't even compromise to have babies)

    however I couldn't not invited my nieces and nephews we are a tight knit family so they'd be missed greatly!

    so my child free wedding now includes 6children (+2 who may be coming from the states! I couldn't say no)

    realistically the closer my friend gets to get due date the more excited I can for her... And I'm already swaying on the no baby thing! Providing no one else pops any out before the day she'll be there with her baby too!

    so I'm hardly one to tell you to stand your ground because I've faltered big time lol!

    do what's right for you!

    • Reply
  • cinnamon009
    Beginner December 2014
    cinnamon009 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    With family its very difficult to do the no kids thing and not have some sort of backlash. If you find a way let me know as we ended up caving!! We are now having close family children at the wedding - so 5 children and one baby.

    It all depends on the theme you have chosen for a wedding - we are having a late winter wedding which is all about adults having fun - cocktails, bands, shots. This may not be other people's dream of a wedding but it's mine. I have spelt this out clearly to family members but even so the back lash has been unreal so we have said they can come and we will be having some very bored children at our wedding. Unfortunately in our families we have some really unruly children - doesn't mean I don't love them but also means I know what a nightmare they will be. Sitting still when we are having readings and saying our vows? not a chance. I've not been to one family do - posh restaurants and everything - where the kids have sat through the meal - they spend the entire time running round screaming.

    Like I said doesn't mean I don't love them but we both know what having kids means we are accepting for our wedding. If you don't want that then stand firmer than I did.

    • Reply
  • J
    Beginner May 2015
    Jayla ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I totally understand wanting an adult only day, however I think I would allow nieces and nephews (don't shoot me but I think you'd feel differntly if they were 'your' nieces) it would be very important to me that they were in the photos. At 8 and 10 they are hardly going to be running around.

    Im having 24 children at my day though, so what do I know! ?

    • Reply
  • Foo
    Beginner June 2014
    Foo ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    The kids in question are 8 & 10 - way past the running around screaming stage.

    • Reply
  • R
    Beginner August 2014
    RLB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    If you have made your decision, and your wedding will not be enjoyable for the girls, then stick to your guns, but maybe sit them down and explain before hand why they aren't coming so they know it's of because you don't love them.

    Are you getting ready at the wedding venue or elsewhere? If it is elsewhere and you are getting a car to the wedding, you could consider having the girls wave you off maybe? That way they could see you in your wedding dress, but you would still have your child free day

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now