Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

C
Beginner

Thoughts needed with gift list decision

Colyflower, 26 February, 2013 at 16:48 Posted on Planning 0 5

Hello everyone

I really thought I had this sorted but now I'm not so sure and I'm just going round in circles. OH isn't any help at the moment so need some advice.

We were going to register a Trailfinders gift list which is who we are intending to book our honeymoon with, we've been together 7 years so this was our alternative to a normal gift list, plus it will be OH's 40th birthday when we are away so it just seemed appropriate for us as it will be a double celebration. I then started to wonder if it was a bit impersonal for some people and so I thought about putting together a very small Amazon gift list as well for people who request it, because some people might not like giving cash gifts.

Then I came across The Bottom Drawer website where you can make a bespoke gift list (for a fee of £89) you can make gift lists more personal by attributing certain amounts of money towards whatever you like and add your own pics and text and set the cost and quantities to whatever you like. You can still add the odd household item or a charity donation as well honeymoon excursions and activities all on the same list without going through particular stores or websites. Ultimately it's a cash gift but I thought it would be nicer if people were contributing to something specific on our honeymoon.

Then this morning I came across an article online where quite a few people were offended that couples had asked for contributions towards their honeymoons. A few were particularly offended that people had attributed a cost towards specific things like a boat trip or massage etc. What is the general feeling regarding honeyfunds, if you were wanting to give a gift would you be happy paying a sum into a Trailfinders account or would you rather know that your money went towards something specific? Would you be offended if someone had put 'Massage for £50' or 'Cocktails for 2 for £15' on their lists?

I have also heard that putting gift details on the invites is bad manners, this is what I'm intending to do but mainly for practical purposes so that all the information that people will need is in one document and not on separate little bits of card and paper that can get lost. I work in communication design so I'm probably seeing this from a different perspective, is it bad manners or just common sense?

So the question is, should I have just the Trailfinders list on it's own, have Trailfinders list and an additional Amazon list if requested by guests, go for one list option at The Bottom Drawer which has everything on it or just mention on the invites that if people wanted to send us a give to get in contact with us and we'll send them the details?

I know whatever we do is not going to please everyone but I'm really trying! It's a tough one.

Any help greatly appreciated

Colyflower

If anyone is interested in the wording I have on the invite at the moment, here it is below:

We’ve been together for a while and have most things we need, for
those of you who would like to send us a gift, a contribution towards our
honeymoon would be greatly appreciated...but please don’t feel obliged!

A gift list is held with Trailfinders under XXXX or XXXX
www.trailfinders.com/giftlist or call 020 7408 9002
Ref: XXXXXXX Closing date: XXXXXXX

Alternatively, we have a small gift list with Amazon,
please contact us if you would us to send you the details.

5 replies

Latest activity by FutureMrsWilliams, 27 February, 2013 at 08:59
  • B
    Beginner August 2013
    butterfly2016 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I personally think I'd prefer to choose something towards a honeymoon as long as there were enough reasonably priced items. I wouldn't like it if all items that were left were £50 +, especially if I was an evening guest.

    • Reply
  • mariannechuaphotography
    mariannechuaphotography ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I don't understand people getting uppity about gift lists, it's like you want to give a gift, but really you want to be asked with flowery manners and you want to give what you like and this or that might offend. If I give a gift I want the receiver to like it, that's what matters to me, if they want money for a honeymoon then that's great, if they want a wooden spoon, that's equally great. Maybe I'm just straight forward about gift giving because of my background. We give cash in red packets, maybe write your name on it in biro if you want the bride and groom to know who it came from. Bottom line, the Chinese don't eff about!

    My answer to your question is ask for whatever you want, if you want money for a honeymoon just do that and forget the arbitary amazon list. Phrase it however befits the language of your invite.

    • Reply
  • C
    Beginner
    Colyflower ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Thanks butterfly, that was one concern I had as well, that by associating certain things at certain prices would be restrictive and also it would take me a lot of time to compile the list in a way that still gave people lots of options even at the end without looking greedy. Trailfinders is an open account and people can make whatever donations they can afford, be it £10 or £50, so maybe our original decision was the right one after all. I think we will stick with the Trailfinders list and also give people the option of contacting us if they'd prefer to get us something else.

    OH is working 24/7 at the moment and organising a wedding on my own is quite daunting and exhausting, sometimes you just need to tell someone what's on your mind for you to think clearly.

    Colyflower

    • Reply
  • C
    Beginner
    Colyflower ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Thanks Marianne, you're right, we should just do what we think is right, as mentioned above, OH is not able to help at the moment so when I'm left with these decisions on my own I start questioning myself. I know that most of our friends will be more than happy with our choice and they know how much we need this holiday.

    • Reply
  • mariannechuaphotography
    mariannechuaphotography ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It is a shame OH isn't helping more, is it worth sitting down with him and reminding him it's both your days and you'd like him to be involved? Sometimes blokes get a bit rubbish at helping because they get daunted by the whole thing and society gives us the impression that a wedding is a "bride's day" when technically it's two people getting married Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • F
    Beginner April 2013
    FutureMrsWilliams ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    This!!

    Glad someone else sees it how I do, I was beginning to think I was the only one. As a guest I am happy to give money, gifts, honeymoon contributions - basically whatever the couple would like and I would prefer to know what they would like when I get the invitation. We have therefore gone for the be honest approach on our invites... been together 12 years, lived together 3 years would like contribution towards honeymoon or double glazing if they want to give us a gift (not quite that wording though obviously lol)

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now