what do you think of these shoes?

Truth by told i love your other shoes more. Also is it a case of you think you should be taller or you want to be taller than your BM's? i just ask because i'm 5'4" and all my bridesmaids are 5'7" and over and i am terrible in anything higher than 2" heels so i might even go for flats. Also mr delicious is 6'5" and i'm used to being short!

These are the shoes i've already got, in case anyone else is wondering!

I prefer the new pair you are looking at!

I prefer the 2nd pair! but them i'm not a high shoe person. ?

I much prefer the new pair! They are lovley!!

I prefer the look of the new pair, but the heels of the old pair (as i'm a shortie too and can't bear big heels!)

so i am no help at all.

go with whichever are more comfortable - you will be in them ALL DAY.

The higher pair look cheap...sorry!

Much prefer your original ones...or pehaps same style but higher heel.

TBH I really don't think it'll matter how tall you look.

totally disagree

I prefer the new pair! ?

I think the new ones are nice! Not that 'weddingy' but I wouldn't let that stop you!

Have you had your dress fitted yet though? if you had it fitted with old shoes it could be a bit of an ankle-swinger if you are suddenly taller!

I prefer the ones you already got, they are more weddingy and more elegant. Dont worry about being shorter, if BM's are taller than you, you are never going to be taller than them anyway. Stick to what you have and dont create any problems. XX

Oooo that first pair/new pair they would be soooooooooo perfect for my wedding toooooo, very 30s/40s/50 tea dress style anddd with a platform sole you dont get sore balls of feet and you dont feel particularly high up - as my wedding shoes are platforms too.....

get themmmmmmmmmmmmmm...

Another vote for the new pair here! They are really nice and I think they would look lovely with a wedding dress even though they aren't as "weddingy"

They don't look unbearably high either, although they are definitely much higher than the ones you already have. But I'm guessing you can cope with heels anyway, otherwise you'd presumably not be seriously considering them!

An alternative idea is maybe to wear the new ones for the ceremony and pics, and if the heels are really starting to bother you after that you can change into the ones you already have?

Thanks everyone...you're all pretty split with your choices though! (i make it 7 for new pair, 4 for old). I'm not having my dress fitted for another couple of weeks yet so no problem with it being too short if i go for higher heel. I know i'll never be taller than my BM's, so it's not that i think i should be taller than them, just that i'd like to be at least nearly the same height.

Teehee, that's what i thought too... obviously they are a much higher heel than my original pair but i'm hoping they wont feel too high. Have decided to order them and see what they're like IRL. I can always send them back...... ?

I prefer the new pair - way better! Not like a "regular" pointy toe, wedding shoe.