I tried on my dress again and ordered a veil a few weeks ago, but i went for a fingertip length when I originally wanted a cathedral length. I was happy at the time because a cathedral didn't feel like I wanted it to and the fingertip did seem to and showed off the detailing of my dress nicely. But now I keep looking at the photos and thinking I should have stuck to my guns and gone for the 2 part cathedral anyway even though the shorter one is still nice.
I have a quite delicately detailed ballgown dress and every ballgown I see has a cathedral veil which I love the look of. As my dress is detailed it seemed better to go for a shorter one and keep the 2 layers on all night and still see the dress. At the time I was happy with my choice but now I'm not sure if it is what I'm after??? I had the option to remove part of the veil (the long bit) and keep the short bit on.