walking down the aisle song

I'm being indecisive and wondered if I could get some impartial opinions please? I have two potential songs to walk down the aisle to, how long will I love you ellie goulding's version and you'll never walk alone piano instrumental. Other half is a massive liverpool fan so was going to have you'll never walk alone as a surprise for him as he's leaving this decision to me as he says its my entrance song. I keep flitting between the two and just cant choose. I'm worried you'll never walk alone might be seen as a strange choice I suppose. I've discussed it with my bridesmaids and two of them laughed (not helpful lol but maybe didnt realise it wouldnt sound like football fans singing) and the other two thought it was a lovely idea and he would like it (one of them is his sister). Another option could be to have you'll never walk alone as tthe signing the register song and have how long will I love you to walk down the aisleto. We're having I'm a believer to walk back out to as shrek was the first film we watched together all those years ago!