Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

W
Beginner

Fiancé does not want a best man for our wedding!!

Wifeysoontobe, 22 September, 2010 at 13:19 Posted on Planning 0 14

My partner and I are getting married next summer, and at the moment I have asked my older sister to be bridesmaid. I did want more, but I don't really feel I have many "genuine" friends I could trust that would be really there for me on the day.

Anyway, the main point is my fiancé is refusing to have a best man. Myself, my sister, my mum and his parents have all said we need you to have someone as it's just not right without one. My fiancé is a nice person and has lots of aquaintances but no "friends" as such, apart from his boss, who he works very closely with, which he goes out with occasionally. I have suggested my OH asks his boss to be best man, and he doesn't think his boss would want to do it, plus he doesn't think he needs one.

He is completely adamant on this and all I can think about is the photos looking funny as there will be absence of another man next to him! I have suggested my sister's boyfriend to be alongside him, but he has refused as him nor I get on with him that well.

Has anyone else had this happen, and what did you do?

I might also add to give anyone a bit of background that he has said all along he's quite happy in staying as partners rather than a married couple, but that he would get married for my sake and our future children's sake. Believe me, I've endured many months having a conscience struggle of whether to go though with getting married or not, and he convinced me he would be completely happy in marrying me, but is quite a shy person so does not understand the "big showy traditions" a wedding would normally bring. So I'm not willing to push anything on him as I'm worried I might take it too far and snap, and tell me he wants it called off! Not that he would, but the worry is always there!!!

Help!

Wifeysoontobe

14 replies

Latest activity by debmci, 24 September, 2010 at 12:44
  • A
    Beginner August 2011
    amythest76 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    What about his dad? or does he have brothers? i think if he doesnt want one then so be it, my oh said if his best mate said no he wouldnt have one...

    I really dont think it will matter in photos at all...x

    • Reply
  • *JLS*
    Beginner July 2012
    *JLS* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Aw that's a shame, does he have any female friends that he would class as close? Nowadays there are more and more guys chosing ladies as their best person as they were closer to them than a man.

    He may come round to it in his own time, but as you have said I wouldn't push the subject too much.

    I'm sorry I can't offer better advice Jx

    • Reply
  • tmr1234
    Beginner June 2011
    tmr1234 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    We are not having best man or brids maids as you really do not need them you just need 2 ppl to sigh for you we are having are mums

    • Reply
  • ajdown
    VIP September 2011
    ajdown ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Which is more important?

    Having a 'best man' which your h2b doesn't want?

    or both of you having a great day and starting your new life together?

    If he doesn't want one, then I'm not convinced there's any need he "has" to have one - any more than you need a church, fancy car, posh reception venue, posh dress, etc etc.

    All you need to get married is a licensed venue, registrar, two witnesses and the "I do's". Everything else is just fluff, at the end of the day.

    The role of the best man is to be emotional support for the groom, and make sure he gets there on time looking decent. If he can manage that himself then that's fine.

    Are you sure it's not that he doesn't want a stag night? I've made it very clear I don't want one, and hope that people will respect my wishes. I know some people - usually based on bad experiences at other people's - have stag night issues.

    • Reply
  • judeclarke
    Beginner October 2011
    judeclarke ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    He doesn't have to have a best man - there's no rule that says he must. My OH is having his sister as best person, but if she had declined we wouldn't have one.As has been said before, you only need a registrar and 2 witnesses for it to be legal.

    Maybe you need to tell him how important the whole 'wedding' thing is to you. It's your chance to be a princess for a day, and if his general apathy for the event is affecting you then you need to talk to him. Maybe if he can see how much it means to you he'll go with it, but if he just wants a quiet wedding you're going to have to compromise.

    • Reply
  • Little Madam
    Beginner
    Little Madam ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I agree with the other comments - if he doesnt want one, thats fine.!

    Don't worry about the photos - you won't even notice it at the time - you'll have more important things to worry over.

    • Reply
  • W
    Beginner
    Wifeysoontobe ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Thanks to everyone who replied, its made me feel so much better! I've never heard of a groom not having a best man at a wedding, but then again I've only been to 2, so what do I know!! I've just decided today I am going to have another bridesmaid, so the witnesses and photos part shouldnt be a problem now. I always thought having a best man was to give the groom support and organise stag do etc but my OH does not seem bothered about not having one in the slightest! And I want to keep him happy!

    Thanks everyone.

    Wifeysoontobe x

    • Reply
  • ajdown
    VIP September 2011
    ajdown ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    A lot of weddings seems to be about 'expectations' rather than what the couple actually want - especially with 'external pressure' put on by friends and family.

    I'm quite adamant I don't want a stag night - I see no reason to 'celebrate my freedom whilst I still can' because I'm not giving up my freedom - I'm gaining something far more important. A number of friends can't figure it out because they were looking forward to a night of beer and strippers or something else - neither of which I particularly have any interest in.

    I'm sure it'll all work out great for you - the most important thing is "keep communicating", far more than the colour of the bridesmaid's shoes or whether you should pick that shade of pink or that shade of pink for the table decorations....

    • Reply
  • Peter
    Peter ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I understand the logic of this although I saw my down to earth stag night as a celebration of the end of one era and the start of another.

    • Reply
  • Peter
    Peter ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    BTW Wifeysoontobe over the years of photographing weddings I have on occasions come across several no best man weddings....it does happen.

    • Reply
  • froggy29400
    Beginner October 2010
    froggy29400 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    H2B was adamant he didn't want a best man, and it annoyed me for a bit but then I thought "that's his choice". Randomly one night he asked his best friend from primary school to be his Best Man (they lost contact for years but are in touch again). That was only last month and we're getting married in 1 month!

    • Reply
  • HorseFan
    Beginner September 2010
    HorseFan ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    We are not having a best man!

    • Reply
  • justpeachy81
    Beginner October 2011
    justpeachy81 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    My Fiancee has aked his best friend from school to be best man, and he agreed, however as we're getting married in Florida we are aware that as this guy is quite unreliable, that he may not actually come (he hasn't asked when wedding is or anything!)....but OH isn't bothered. He says he doesn't need one, so what's the fuss?!

    • Reply
  • shoegal01
    Beginner October 2010
    shoegal01 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I think its totally fine for him not to have a best man.

    I dont think it will look odd in the photos at all.

    Surely its better for him to be happy and have no best man than to have someone he dosnt want

    • Reply
  • debmci
    debmci ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It would be a wee bit strange without one, but you could suggest he could have someone as a "groomsman" maybe instead if you really think you would like some1 else there with him on the day. Being called groomsman, kind of mekes it a wee bit less close of a relationship, if you know what i mean. I can't see why you couldnt have one mind you. If he's more comfortable, then why not. I was BM before and had no partner, and it was fine. He does need a witness tho, so talk to him about that, and maybe it would work that way for you.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now