Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Rod
Beginner

Handmade Weddings....thoughts?

Rod, 21 June, 2013 at 10:31 Posted on Planning 0 52

A woman at work is getting married, she is making almost everything her self to Number 1 ) save money and number 2) make it more 'personal'. Some of the stuff she's shown me looks alright, but the majority is a bit...well...blah.

I am not a fan of weddings that are OBVIOUSLY handmade...they can look a bit like a childrens party - paper decorations, handmade invitations and name tags and balloons as centrepieces...etc. It can all be a bit tacky if you ask me - I know there are some people who have that crafty element to them but most people dont...!

What are your thoughts? Are you making stuff yourself or would you rather spend a bit extra and get a professional to do it...?

52 replies

Latest activity by Mary C to be K, 21 June, 2013 at 23:53
  • ATB
    Beginner August 2014
    ATB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    What type of things has she made?

    I think there is sometimes a fine line between personal handcrafted and 'homemade to save cash' and it can be very obvious.

    I'm having a home made wedding, to save money in some aspects - but mostly because I like making things and think I'm ok at it. It's my style, and will give me satisfaction when I (hopefully) get compliments on my efforts! Sometimes home made isn't the cheapest option. I'm making my own invites at around £3 each - where I could buy a whole batch on Vistaprint for a couple of quid. In crafting circles people get very upset when home made is seen as a cheapskate option - when it's often not.

    Often I see things made by other crafters that I love, and know that I could have a bash myself at making something similar, but it would never be as good as the original, take me a lot of effort because I don't have the skills they do, then buy materials on top of that. In this case I'll be buying some things I've seen for my wedding, that are handcrafted but by someone else! I'm happy to pay for them and support another crafter!

    • Reply
  • *Bea*
    Beginner October 2011
    *Bea* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Fancy card, lace and PVA does not a talented crafter make.

    I have seen some horrendous attempts at homemade often by misguided brides thinking it will be the cheaper option, when more often than not they spend more because they mess it up and looks cheap anyway.

    Don't get me wrong I love handmade items , just if they are done well.

    Invitations with those silver/gold foil 'invitation' stickers make my blood boil!

    • Reply
  • Rod
    Beginner
    Rod ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    You are obviously good at crafty stuff and yours would match, if not better, that which has been done by a professional so, no issue.

    Tissue paper flowers and sugar paper table plans however...nope.

    • Reply
  • Rod
    Beginner
    Rod ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    Urgh I hate those foil stickers! *shudder*

    • Reply
  • ATB
    Beginner August 2014
    ATB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Talk of them is making me a bit itchy! Rubber stamping is easier and looks way better!

    Is she showing you pics of tissue paper flowers Rod? Like the type kids make in primary 1 for mother's day?

    • Reply
  • Rod
    Beginner
    Rod ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Yep.

    There are pom poms involved on the table plan.

    I am not going into more details in case she's here haha

    • Reply
  • Pompey
    Beginner June 2012
    Pompey ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Mum and I made a hell of a lot of stuff for my wedding, not that you would know because we only made things we knew wouldn't look cheap. We didnt make the cake, we don't have those sort of 'crafty' genes.

    • Reply
  • *Bea*
    Beginner October 2011
    *Bea* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It's the same with vintage and shabby chic. A slap of paint on something does not make it chic... Just shabby!

    I also hate the confetti type kits you know the ones that you make favour boxes out of and fill with cheap manky chocolate that costs less than the cardboard box.

    • Reply
  • Skeptical78
    Beginner September 2013
    Skeptical78 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I think it depends. If you're trying to pull of a sophisticated, elegant wedding then I'd steer clear from handmade unless you are a professional 'crafter'. I have seen some truly dire handmade wedding invitations for some very expensive, elegant hotel weddings (one just had a random bit of lace- which looked more like net curtain- and a sequin glued to the front).

    However, if you're hoping that your wedding reception will look more like a kid's 10th birthday party (ie. ME) I think it's fine to make some crappy tack yourself! For example; chip fork place names, ribbon wands and life-preserver napkin rings... ?

    I think it only becomes tack when it's suppose to look sophisticated and classy, and doesn't quite hit the mark. If things have no pretence of being elegant and / or stylish, I'm all for it!

    Don't get me wrong; I'm all for paying someone else to do this for me- I don't particularly enjoy it and I have zero crafty skills- but I'm a bit limited by budget, so it was either make stuff or have the whole thing look a bit sparse.

    • Reply
  • Skeptical78
    Beginner September 2013
    Skeptical78 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    The ONLY acceptable context for foil stickers is in a primary school classroom when you have done good work.

    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner August 2014
    MOMB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I love receiving cards with a gold foil twiddly lettering; it's always come from either an elderly relative ('bought it at a craft stall at the day centre') or a small child (my YD makes all her own cards and loves these! - she's eight).

    I can't imagine why someone would choose that for an wedding invitation. Maybe a generational thing?

    • Reply
  • tayto
    Beginner May 2013
    tayto ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Can someone flash me this gold/silver foil lettering you refer to??

    • Reply
  • *Bea*
    Beginner October 2011
    *Bea* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content


    Like this...

    • Reply
  • O
    Beginner September 2013
    oggers86 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I made my invitations and will be making the table plan and table names. I am very impressed with the way the invites turned out considering I am not crafty. Being a perfectionist everything was measured to the exact mm and anything that looked awful was thrown out and done again.

    • Reply
  • ATB
    Beginner August 2014
    ATB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I think they were once seen as the easiest option - and are often pushed with other 'make your own' items for new crafters - mainly those who's first venture into cardmaking is their wedding invitations. Stickers are easier to store and less messy than other methods of adding a greeting - hence being easiest for older card makers or kids!

    • Reply
  • ATB
    Beginner August 2014
    ATB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Agreed. I'd hope my styling and home made items will be co-ordinated and professional looking, but I also need to keep in mind my venue. It's a village hall and I need to work with that 'theme' rather than dress it up to be something it's not. If I go too all out and posh (I'd Love massive candleabras with flowers in the middle of them) it will look stupid, like I'm trying to make the old village hall look like a posh wedding venue. Hence why it will look much better with bunting, flowers and lace. I'm not going too rustic so hoping it can all go together leaning towards the elegant, rather than too 'I made this myself to save money'.

    The same goes with beautiful posh hotel venues which are then styled with hessian ect. It just doesn't go. Just because rustic/shabby is in fashion at the moment, you need to work with your venue to compliment and thus get the best overall look.

    • Reply
  • Jaysmonkey
    Beginner August 2014
    Jaysmonkey ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'm a crafty sort and support small professional craft businesses where possible and will be doing so with my wedding.

    For example my flowergirl wands are from Folksy the UK Handcrafted website and they are perfect.

    I actually have a jewellery business, so will be making all my jewellery and the gifts for BMs and such.

    I'm also making the wedding invites but I've got a custom made stamp from this lovely lady http://www.thisisjusttosay.co/collections/custom-stamps/products/handmade-wedding-stamp, this will be on my invites, save the dates and other stationery.

    The other thing I'm making is the favours but these are relatively simple and don't require much. It's nothing to do with cost, just the favours I'd like to give happen to be these!

    I'm making the button bouquets, mine is almost finished now, but this is very similar to making jewellery so really isn't an issue.

    I'm also making my cake topper because I love experimenting with polymer clay ? and heck I'm pretty good at it too.

    All other decorations as I say will mainly be from the likes of Folksy and Etsy.

    My cake is being made by my SiLTB since she's an awesome cake maker..so makes sense! Plus it needs to be vegan.

    I see nothing wrong with a handmade wedding...just make sure it's done properly, and not rushed.

    • Reply
  • clarehj
    Beginner April 2012
    clarehj ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Nothing was hand-made at ours. A) I'm not crafty/creative with materials so would have looked cr*p, and b) I'm just lazy.

    • Reply
  • WickyWack
    Beginner July 2013
    WickyWack ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Fortunately I am quite crafty so things like invitations, table plan, centre pieces, bunting etc look really good. Saying that, I did make myself a brooch bouquet and when I finished it my response was "meh". I wasn't very good at all, so I am now having fresh flowers by a florist.

    The thing is as well, people don't want to offend so if you show ppl your handmade invitations that look a bit naff, they probably won't say anything!

    • Reply
  • Little Pixie
    Beginner September 2011
    Little Pixie ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Unless you have a real talent for it then it shoul be kept to a minimum IMO. My favourite is people making their own bouquets. 9 out 10 look shocking, fake flowers and bits of feather. Yak.

    • Reply
  • ATB
    Beginner August 2014
    ATB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I have just made a comment along those lines - I may be flamed for it.

    • Reply
  • *Funky*
    Beginner January 2001
    *Funky* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I just don't get the whole DIY/crafty/vintage thing.

    Yes there are a few very crafty people among us who can pull it off many can't. I blame all this on Kirsty Allsop she should have just stuck with Location, Location, Location!

    Also why do middle class people feel the need jump on the band wagon? Why anyone would want to pretend to be poor and raid charity shops for second hand tat is beyond me.

    • Reply
  • Icklefee
    Super May 2014
    Icklefee ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I love the idea of a handmade wedding but in reality I am useless at it. I have a very crafty friend who is covering my jam jars for me, I am making my place cards because there is not a huge amount I can do wrong on them.... but my friend will write them for me. So I can have my "handmade wedding" I am buying items from crafters, stationary will be handmade, bouquets will be handmade, venue decor will be handmade..... just not by me! Etsy is my best friend.

    • Reply
  • Skeptical78
    Beginner September 2013
    Skeptical78 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I would. Not to their face, obviously, but I would. In fact, I have!

    They really were SHOCKING invitations though. They looked like they should have contained feminine hygiene products. I expected to open it and a pantyliner to fall out.

    • Reply
  • Skeptical78
    Beginner September 2013
    Skeptical78 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    Tru dat. The key word here is 'pretend' to be poor. I AM poor! And even I wouldn't dream of firking around in charity shops. I'll happily donate to their cause; I don't want a tatty old jumper or dog-eared book in return.

    I have a friend who is better off than me, and she and her sister are always trekking to the 'posher' bits of the county to rummage around in second hand shops. Why? If you have the money, just buy new clothes!

    (Although, I AM thinking hen do outfit right now...a charity shop might be the perfect place if I can get over my fear of potentially buying a dead person's clothes)

    • Reply
  • Rod
    Beginner
    Rod ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    FF I actually really like your invitations!

    FWIW my H was insistent our invitations looked good as they set the tone for the day...so ner haha!

    • Reply
  • ATB
    Beginner August 2014
    ATB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Haha suppose it's the same as all aspects of wedding planning, differing priorities! I want my invites to be the best anyone has every received (they may say it was a sh*t party!) but I'm not so hung up on flowers. My cousin on the other hand wants to spend a huge amount on flowers so will just go for plan simple/cheap stationery.

    My friend's dad recently made her invitations and they were nice, so I told her so. Her bouquet on the other hand was hideous - I told her this also. My mum was horrified but I was confident in my opinion as I could tell by the way my friend was holding it that she thought it was hidieous too (she'd had no say in it).

    • Reply
  • Ali_G
    Beginner October 2012
    Ali_G ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I made a lot of stuff for our wedding. In hindsight, I really don't like our invitations - think I could have done a better job - but everyone else seemed to like them.

    Having said that, my invites cost me about 30 quid to make, for 150 invites. I just don't see the point in spending hundreds of pounds on invites which are, more than likely, just going to get thrown away after the event - I'd rather spend that money on wine.

    • Reply
  • BertB
    Beginner July 2013
    BertB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'm not keen on things that are clearly home made that could just have been bouight and look much better. The only things I am doing myself if stamping peoples names on place cards, putting some lace around jars and making the table plan. I definately wouldnt do my own invires or flowers, they would look shocking.

    • Reply
  • Kentish Gal
    Beginner July 2013
    Kentish Gal ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    Okay - which one of my colleagues are you???!

    I've bodged a stack of handmade stuff. It does NOT look like something you'd drool over on Pinterest. Some of it is fine, some defintiely is not. I made it with the best of intentions, because I wanted to put as much effort and love in to the whole thing. I am not interested in impressing my guests, but want them to know I care about them. I don't have a huge budget and the day reflects that. Everyone will have fun, though, and if people really don't like it the good news is they'll never have to come to another wedding of mine Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • WickyWack
    Beginner July 2013
    WickyWack ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Pinterest has a lot to answer for!

    • Reply
  • tayto
    Beginner May 2013
    tayto ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    A woman after my own heart, hahaha!! I'm the exact same, I made our invites and wasn't terribly 100% happy with them but our guests loved them. I *did* use the silver foil that lots of people on here don't like and I did that purely to make them cheap & quick. I do make cards as a hobby but, I had to make almost 200 for the wedding! Yes, I do know I could have got them made professionally but that was expensive and, as a card maker, I did want to do them myself but producing 200 invites with lots of painstaking detail is not what I like about making cards. I'm pretty sure, actually, that the money we saved on the invites definitely went on wine..... lots of it & I used the bottles as part of the guestbook idea!!! ?

    • Reply
  • You voted for . Add a comment 👇

    ×


    Related articles

    Premium members

    • Q
      Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

    General groups

    Hitched article topics

    Contest icon

    Win £3,000 for your wedding

    Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

    Enter now