Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Sloth

Need some perspective - WWYD

Sloth, 23 May, 2012 at 19:50 Posted on Planning 0 17

Would you care if someone had the same Wedding Cake as you?

My good friend is getting married 6 months after me, we are both bridesmaids for each other. So far we have been lucky as we have both gone for very different weddings so have wanted only a couple of the same things but they have worked out on their own. My other bridesmaid has offered to make my cake as a wedding present, is very excited and is getting her Gran to teach her to make icing flowers - I have been very layed back about the design as she has good taste, didn't want to dictate what is a present - after several ideas she came to me with we came to a conclusion. I was then out with the bm also getting married and she mentioned cake, and I remembered she had shown me what she has chosen and showed me a few months ago - a M&S cake very similar design. It is very popular at the moment. I told her that was the design we had come to but cut the conversations short as another friend was with us but my bridesmaid did say we couldn't have the same wedding cake

My first instinct was a disappointed I will have to change mine, but I have delayed telling my cake friend as the more I look at other cakes the more I want that design. I am limited as my friend is learning flowers so it will be based around those, and I cannot find others I really like, and I do not mind having the same cake with different colours. People around me are saying I shouldn't change, but I am not sure if thats just as its a bit of a sensitive subject.

Am I being spoilt and should I just tell my cake friend we have to find another design, or is it ok to want to stick to the same agreed design.

17 replies

Latest activity by venart, 25 May, 2012 at 15:49
  • llindsey
    Beginner June 2012
    llindsey ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I would just have the cake, if your bridesmaid asks again what you are having, just tell her your other friend is making it, so it will be a surprise.

    Im sure she wont care on the day anyway. I wouldnt care if someone had the same cake as me.

    If you decide to tell her you are keeping the cake as it, you could point out that nobody will remember what kind of cake you had once her wedding comes around!

    • Reply
  • T
    Beginner July 2012
    Thursday Bride ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Have the cake your friend is making and the design you like Its a lovely gesture for her to make it with a little help from her gran and with only just learning you can hardly ask her to change tack now

    PS great idea of llindsey to say its a surprise and you don't know!

    • Reply
  • Nutella
    Beginner March 2013
    Nutella ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Have the cake and stick with the design you've chosen.

    Might sound harsh but if it bothers your friend that much when she sees it on your w-day she could always change hers! But its not like either of you have deliberatley copied each other.

    • Reply
  • *Mini*
    Beginner January 2012
    *Mini* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Not in th slightest but then again I really sont see the importance of a cake in the grand scheme of things?

    Just change the choice of cake and then you don't have to worry? Thats what I would do anyway.

    • Reply
  • *Funky*
    Beginner January 2001
    *Funky* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Who's getting married first you or your friend?

    If i showed you my cake and then you wanted the same/similar and were getting married before me, i would be pi$$ed as people may think i had copied you when in fact i chose my design first.

    If you had the same/similar cake as me but were married after my wedding i would be very flattered that they liked it enough to want the same/similar.

    • Reply
  • B
    Brian Parkes LSWPP (HIB) ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    No, I wouldn't give a fig if somebody had the same cake as me.

    • Reply
  • Mrs C
    Beginner March 2011
    Mrs C ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It's a cake.

    It is the act of the cutting the cake that is important, your first joint task as Mr & Mrs.

    • Reply
  • kharv
    Beginner March 2012
    kharv ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    As we forgot to do this, I can safely say I wouldn't be bothered if someone had the same cake as me!

    I only ever remember cake toppers, not the actual cake itself to be honest.

    • Reply
  • Pinky6
    Beginner June 2012
    Pinky6 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    SQUEEEEEEEEE!!

    I wouldn't care either way and don't really see why she would bother that much if you're cakes were the same. Just be honest with her, is it really worth arguing/stressing over?

    • Reply
  • AmnesiaCustard
    Beginner June 2011
    AmnesiaCustard ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I only remember a cake if it is really different (ie a stack of chocolate brownies). All those white layered jobbies look the same to me! I really wouldn't worry about this.

    • Reply
  • *gnashers*
    Beginner October 2013
    *gnashers* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I wouldn't worry - it is, at the end of the day, just a cake, and isn't that important in comparison to the rest of the day.

    Like someone said, your friend may see yours and if it is similar, change her mind.

    • Reply
  • ForTheLoveOfMrsBrown
    Beginner January 2012
    ForTheLoveOfMrsBrown ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    This. It would have to be pretty spectacular for me to remember anyone's wedding cake. Like, Choccywoccydoodah spectacular.

    • Reply
  • W
    Beginner July 2012
    Wherts2b ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I know i'm going against the majority but have to agree with this. I would be p!ssed if I was your friend, and probably even more annoyed if you pretended not to have known. It is important to some people and your friend may have put alot of thought into hers and by you having it may make it feel less special

    • Reply
  • T
    Beginner
    Trickers ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    It's a cake. There's more important things to worry about.

    • Reply
  • pandorasbox
    Beginner August 2012
    pandorasbox ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    I agree. Getting OH this for his bday but I reallllly want it as wedding cake instead:


    I think you should keep the design you want and not worry about the other one, as others have said it will look totally different when amongst your decor and venue.

    • Reply
  • Blonde Viki
    Beginner July 2012
    Blonde Viki ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    This is the best thing to do IMO.

    I wouldn't be bothered at all about someone having the same cake as me Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • venart
    Beginner June 2013
    venart ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    This!

    Why does it matter if the cake is similar?

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


Related articles

Premium members

  • Q
    Qa Test I got married in August - 2022 North Yorkshire

General groups

Hitched article topics

Contest icon

Win £3,000 for your wedding

Join Hitched Rewards, where you can win £3,000 simply by planning your wedding with us. Start collecting entries, it's easy and free!

Enter now