Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

B
Beginner June 2015

Paying for Bridesmaids?!! **Updated**

Brooksy, 19 May, 2014 at 16:38

Posted on Planning 53

I am going to be a bridesmaid for my brothers partner later this year, she has asked us to buy our own bridesmaids dresses, which in theory I am fine with as my logic was 'I would be buying a new outfit for my brothers wedding anyway, so it’s no different to buy it her chosen colour'. When she...

I am going to be a bridesmaid for my brothers partner later this year, she has asked us to buy our own bridesmaids dresses, which in theory I am fine with as my logic was 'I would be buying a new outfit for my brothers wedding anyway, so it’s no different to buy it her chosen colour'. When she asked, she basically said; buy whatever you like, as long as it is in the colour scheme - perfect.

As things progress with the dress hunting, she is starting to get more and more prescriptive about what we can and can't have. I initially wanted to buy a two birds style dress from BHS, full length because I hate my legs, but she has decided that we can't have anything stretchy.... ok... then we couldn't have full length because ‘they always drag on the floor and look awful’, then we could have full length, now she 'doesn't care'.

I am quite busty, and wanted a dress with straps... or some sort of support; she prefers strapless dresses and has pulled a face at anything I have shown her with straps, sleeves, sheer necklines etc. I am trying to pick something she will like and I will not look like a prostitute in!

She has now put forward a shortlist of 5 dresses, which she likes and would like myself and the other 2 bridesmaids to choose from. She wants us all to pick a different dress from the 5. Needless to say, all 5 are strapless and knee length. If this is what she wants fine, I just wish she had said this all along rather than saying ‘pick whatever you want’.

My issue is that the CHEAPEST dress on the short list is £195!! The most expensive is around £400. Personally, I think this is asking a lot for somebody to pay, especially as we then have to get shoes (*have* to be the same colour as the dress, so can’t wear something I already have), jewellery, hair, makeup, overnight accommodation night before and night of the wedding, hen weekend away. She is not having a big budget wedding; her own dress only cost £300, so I can’t understand why she thinks we will all be able to pay out this much! I am saving like MAD for my own wedding, one of her other bridesmaids is still in college and only works 4 hours per week, so never has any cash.

My other issue is that if I am paying for the dress, I want to have something that I can wear again and feel comfortable in, which I know I won’t if my legs are on show and my boobs are popping out!

Am I being unreasonable here? Apparently the other bridesmaids have told her to just pick something and they will buy it (although I don’t know how they can afford it!).

Ladies - are you paying for your girls, or are they paying for themselves? And if they are paying are they picking? And how much would you expect them to spend?

I have shown her some similar dresses that are around the £80 mark but she keeps saying that she doesn’t like them or they look naff – don’t know what else to do!!

53 replies

  • mustard_mitt
    Beginner September 2015
    mustard_mitt ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'm sorry Brooksy, I know she's your FSIL but she sounds like a total nightmare. The epitome of a bridezilla!

    It sounds to me like she felt forced to have you as a bm and she's showing she's had her hand forced by treating you this way. Publicly she's saying she's fine with it but she's clearly not and I think that's why she's being so demanding with you but fine with her chosen bms.

    My opinion: save yourself the heartache and problems and step down now, because if she's like this about the dress, what else is she going to be difficult with you about? She obviously wants you to step down, otherwise she'd be more willing to work with you and accept you can't afford to spend this sort of ridiculous money on a dress you'll wear once. She doesn't sound to me like the sort of person who'll accept any suggestion you make.

    I'm really sorry to say this to you, but I really think stepping down as her bm is your only option here, because I think July will come and you'll be forced to anyway.

    • Reply
  • Elixia
    Beginner March 2014
    Elixia ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    Ok, didn't read this probably the first time around. Please step down. she's being a bully, alienating you, judging you through a gritted tooth smile. I'm actually rather angry for you!

    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner August 2014
    MOMB ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    So what are the dress criteria? Perhaps the joint power of hitched can find you something more in budget and suitable.

    • Reply
  • donnyette
    Beginner December 2016
    donnyette ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I totally agree with mustard-mitt and elixia. Please step down now and save yourself upset in 2months time. She is obviously going to veto any dress you pick.

    My sister is now bm and she has been married for 7 years. Sod tradition, you have someone because they are special regardless if they are married or not!

    Im very angry for you too. My sis hasnt got a massive budget. She has found a stunning dress on ebay for £25 and leaves money to get her shoes. She is doing her own make up and im paying for her hair to be done.

    Your fsil sounds like a right nightmare. It really sounds like she doesnt really want you as a bm. To have the other 2 stay at her house and make you get a hotel is TOTALLY out of order!!

    Let us know how you get on x

    • Reply
  • Paula @ Ollievision
    Paula @ Ollievision ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I've just seen your updates! You are being very tolerant and understanding. I think for your own sake you should step down now. Let her be with her special bridesmaids and you relax instead of being at her right hand.

    • Reply
  • PinkButterfly
    Beginner June 2014
    PinkButterfly ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    If I were you I'd step down and tell her to get stuffed!

    then go out out and buy myself a lovely cream dress to wear to her wedding as a guest! (Only kidding about the last part... Maybe not)

    but really your being too tolerant... She is taking the mick! Don't put up with it!

    • Reply
  • Elixia
    Beginner March 2014
    Elixia ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    hahaha! oh if only!

    • Reply
  • H
    Beginner August 2014
    HundredMonkeys ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Stop being a doormat (even though you seem like a very kind and tolerant one!) and step down as bm. She is manipulating you and probably felt forced into having you as a bm. I think it's shocking that she is treating her future sister in law like this - particularly when expecting you to just turn up all ready and waiting when they get to be with her on the morning. She is being very mean and you need to stop letting her great you so! Politely step down and don't give her any more satisfaction. I also suspect she is probably a bit jealous of you, particularly when she seems to think you are "loaded". Save yourself the stress and nastiness and don't be a bm anymore.

    • Reply
  • pammy67
    Beginner April 2015
    pammy67 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    What a selfish thoughtless so and so and a spoilt brat she is. Sorry but I'm spitting at your last two posts. I would "step down" (a euphemism for telling her to shove it). The whole way she is treating you is disgusting. She's not treating you like a bridesmaid at all. She is treating you like something you'd wipe of your foot. Save your emotions and money and do/spend it on what you want. I'm not saying don't go to her wedding, but go as a guest.

    • Reply
  • AuntieBJ
    Beginner September 2014
    AuntieBJ ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message

    This. 100% this. She is treating you atrociously and you have to walk away from this. Make an excuse if you have to, but please step down x

    • Reply
  • A
    Beginner July 2014
    Aykay ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I cant believe how awful she is being and o am amazed you have not seriously lost your rag with her. You deserve a sainthood,let alone a nice dress.

    Please just tell her to do one....tho you seem too nice a person to do that but I I hope you do at least step refuse to be a bridesmaid.... and enjoy planning your own wedding.

    Or mention how helpful you find this forum and hope she sees everyones comments and realises how badly she is behaving.

    • Reply
  • *Mrs M to be*
    Beginner August 2014
    *Mrs M to be* ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I'm sorry but what a b**ch! She's being so mean to you by not including you in the hen do/ wedding morning plans. As some others have said I'd definitely agree that there's some jealousy there. Maybe she feels you'll be having the bigger/ better wedding or something.

    It's totally unreasonable of her to expect you to buy such an expensive dress (especially when you then say you bought her her veil!). I do feel that there's an an ulterior motive here though. I think she's trying to make things as awkward as possible for you until you step down. God knows why she asked you in the first place if it's such an issue for her.

    After all the things you've said you've done to help out and the way she's treating you, I would 100% be telling her where to stick it!

    • Reply
  • S
    Beginner July 2014
    SunnyOrangeConfetti79 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    Brooksy - you must be an absolute saint! I'm usually a very tolerant person, but I would have completely lost my rag with this woman long ago and told her exactly where to shove her bridesmaids dress. Please don't waste any more of your time looking for dresses that you know she won't approve, only to know that you're going to be sidelined anyway even if you do find something. I'm actually really seething on your behalf from reading your last couple of posts - sorry, I know she's marrying your brother, but she sounds like a total b*tch.

    • Reply
  • Icklefee
    Super May 2014
    Icklefee ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    What an absolute witch. She either has her head completely up her own derrière or she's provoking you into stepping down. There is no way that dresses cannot be found within your budget that meet her standards. More Lee and Mark Lesley both have them starting around £115. Monsoon, debenhams, bhs, lipsy, quiz, house of fraser, John Lewis, good old ebay. .. She cannot hate every single dress. I would tell her straight. You are not prepared to spend that on a dress, especially when expected to pay for a hotel room too and she's on her own with the wedmin while you get on with your day. Put it to bed now before the fall out from her wedding gets a chance to spoil your own.

    • Reply
  • Erin8
    Beginner June 2014
    Erin8 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    What a nasty piece of work she is. Being demanding about making you spend lots of money on a dress you can't really choose, makes assumptions about your finances (which are really none of her business) and not including you much on the wedding day. What does your mother and brother make of this out of curiosity? I am quite stubborn so l would be tempted to make her sack me? But then again l am guessing your wedding is approaching fast and you don't need the stress or hassle of it all.

    • Reply
  • smokesignal
    Beginner August 2015
    smokesignal ·
    • Report
    • Hide content
    View quoted message



    This!! As you can tell from the massive hitched response, what she's doing is AWFUL. Definitely just step down, especially because you two are going to be in each other's lives now for life probably! I agree that I don't know how you're being so patient, but as you seem like the sort of person who can manage it, I would just step down quietly and try and salvage your relationship with her! I can't believe she hasn't thought about that though, it's so not the way you want to enter into someone's family! Just worry about your own wedding!

    xoxo

    • Reply
  • BeccaM2b83
    Beginner December 2015
    BeccaM2b83 ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I agree with the others I'm afraid. She's being a bully. She wants you to make the decision to step down rather than be the one to ask you to. Normally I'd say don't let the bully win but in this case I think the others are right. Don't let her stress you out or be cruel and alienate you. After all, what's the point in being a Bridesmaid if you aren't there to help and she doesn't want you to. Just go and enjoy the day with your h2b and make a note of all the things that will be better at your wedding..... Smiley winking

    • Reply
  • MadamRed
    Beginner April 2017
    MadamRed ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    She may be a lovely person normally, but it sounds like this wedding has brought out the worst in her. If I were you, I'd step down now.

    • Reply
  • L
    Beginner August 2014
    LAR.2.LAA ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I don't think you're being unreasonable at all! If she wants you to be her bridesmaid then she has to respect that you want to feel comfortable on the day. I'm having 2 bridesmaids (my sister who's 11 and my best friend who'll be my MOH). I said to my MOH from the beginning that I wanted her to feel comfortable on the day and sent her links to a few dresses that I liked and said that if she found anything else that she liked, to send me a link. It was a mutual decision when we found her perfect dress. I paid for it (£70) and a matching shrug for her and she's paid for her shoes etc which I think is reasonable!

    I do think that even £195 is a bit steep for a dress that you're probably never gonna wear again - I didn't pay much more than that for my dress (£250) and I'm the bride!!

    I got my MOH's dress from evica.co.uk - great site! Hers is a Cadbury Purple floor length dress, strapless but very flattering!

    If the bride isn't willing to compromise somewhere then I'd highly recommend stepping down as bridesmaid!

    Good luck

    x

    • Reply
  • RoseArcana
    RoseArcana ·
    • Report
    • Hide content

    I would certainly be stepping down! Her demands are totally unreasonable!

    Save your sanity and just explain that you don't feel like a BM, but just a tag along and SHE should appreciate what everyone in the family is doing to help her especially mum who is working all the time rather than making diva demands. I would be very angry and would feel silly on the day tbh.

    You sound like such a nice person trying to make her happy but this is taking the biscuit! X

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

General groups

Hitched article topics